Temporary Agency Work in European Labour Law: Evolutionary Perspectives between Harmonisationand Heterogeneity

Download PDF

Contents: 1. The evolutionary process of temporary agency work in the European Union. 1.1. From restrictive approaches to promotional intent within the flexicurity paradigm. 1.2. Directive 2008/104/EC as a pillar of European regulation. 2. National models compared: liberal vs restrictive approaches. 2.1. The Italian regulatory framework between flexibility enhancement and application restrictions. 2.2. Regulation in continental Europe: France and Germany between restrictions and liberalisation. 2.3. The Spanish model: the authorisation system and judgment C-441/23. 2.4. Self-regulation and the role of social partners in the Swedish and Danish systems and the Dutch Waadi Act. 2.5. Post-Brexit United Kingdom: the survival of the Agency Workers Regulations. 3. The principle of equal treatment and its operational variants. 3.1. Equal treatment in the directive and possible derogations. 3.2. Jurisprudence of the Court of Justice on equal treatment. 4. The “reasonable temporariness” of assignments. 4.1. Temporariness as a defining element of temporary agency work. 4.2. The “reasonable temporariness” in judgments C-681/2018 and C-232/2020. 4.3. The absence of uniform criteria and consequent case-by-case application uncertainties. 5. The singular case of staff leasing. 5.1. The currently pending preliminary question. 5.2. Textual and systematic elements underlying the preliminary question. 6. Concluding reflections: implementation status and future scenarios for a sustainable balance between flexibility and protection.

1. The evolutionary process of temporary agency work in the European Union
1.1. From restrictive approaches to promotional intent within the flexicurity paradigm
Temporary agency work constitutes one of the most emblematic institutions of the flexicurity paradigm characterising the contemporary EuroDiritti Lavori Mercati International, 2026, i pean labour law framework, which continually seeks an appropriate balance between workers’ protection and companies’ adaptability needs1. The evolution of the European approach to temporary agency work
indeed reflects a broader rethinking of labour policies in the European Union, marked by a shift from a protection model based on job security to one centred on employment security